Hearing the shape of a drum

Mathematically ideal drums with membranes of these two different shapes (but otherwise identical) would sound the same, because the eigenfrequencies are all equal, so the timbral spectra would contain the same overtones. This example was constructed by Gordon, Webb and Wolpert. Notice that both polygons have the same area and perimeter.

To hear the shape of a drum is to infer information about the shape of the drumhead from the sound it makes, i.e., from the list of overtones, via the use of mathematical theory.

"Can One Hear the Shape of a Drum?" is the title of a 1966 article by Mark Kac in the American Mathematical Monthly which made the question famous, though this particular phrasing originates with Lipman Bers. Similar questions can be traced back all the way to physicist Arthur Schuster in 1882. For his paper, Kac was given the Lester R. Ford Award in 1967 and the Chauvenet Prize in 1968.

The frequencies at which a drumhead can vibrate depend on its shape. The Helmholtz equation calculates the frequencies if the shape is known. These frequencies are the eigenvalues of the Laplacian in the space. A central question is whether the shape can be predicted if the frequencies are known; for example, whether a Reuleaux triangle can be recognized in this way. Kac admitted that he did not know whether it was possible for two different shapes to yield the same set of frequencies. The question of whether the frequencies determine the shape was finally answered in the negative in the early 1990s by Carolyn S. Gordon, David Webb and Scott A. Wolpert.

Formal statement

More formally, the drum is conceived as an elastic membrane whose boundary is clamped. It is represented as a domain D in the plane. Denote by λ_n the Dirichlet eigenvalues for D: that is, the eigenvalues of the Dirichlet problem for the Laplacian:

${\begin{cases}\Delta u+\lambda u=0\\u|_{\partial D}=0\end{cases}}$

Two domains are said to be isospectral (or homophonic) if they have the same eigenvalues. The term "homophonic" is justified because the Dirichlet eigenvalues are precisely the fundamental tones that the drum is capable of producing: they appear naturally as Fourier coefficients in the solution wave equation with clamped boundary.

Therefore, the question may be reformulated as: what can be inferred on D if one knows only the values of λ_n? Or, more specifically: are there two distinct domains that are isospectral?

Related problems can be formulated for the Dirichlet problem for the Laplacian on domains in higher dimensions or on Riemannian manifolds, as well as for other elliptic differential operators such as the Cauchy–Riemann operator or Dirac operator. Other boundary conditions besides the Dirichlet condition, such as the Neumann boundary condition, can be imposed. See spectral geometry and isospectral as related articles.

The answer

One-parameter family of isospectral drums

Eigenmodes and corresponding eigenvalues of the Laplace operator on the GWW domains

In 1964, John Milnor observed that a theorem on lattices due to Ernst Witt implied the existence of a pair of 16-dimensional flat tori that have the same eigenvalues but different shapes. However, the problem in two dimensions remained open until 1992, when Carolyn Gordon, David Webb, and Scott Wolpert constructed, based on the Sunada method, a pair of regions in the plane that have different shapes but identical eigenvalues. The regions are concave polygons. The proof that both regions have the same eigenvalues uses the symmetries of the Laplacian. This idea has been generalized by Buser, Conway, Doyle, and Semmler who constructed numerous similar examples. So, the answer to Kac's question is: for many shapes, one cannot hear the shape of the drum completely. However, some information can be inferred.

On the other hand, Steve Zelditch proved that the answer to Kac's question is positive if one imposes restrictions to certain convex planar regions with analytic boundary. It is not known whether two non-convex analytic domains can have the same eigenvalues. It is known that the set of domains isospectral with a given one is compact in the C^∞ topology. Moreover, the sphere (for instance) is spectrally rigid, by Cheng's eigenvalue comparison theorem. It is also known, by a result of Osgood, Phillips, and Sarnak that the moduli space of Riemann surfaces of a given genus does not admit a continuous isospectral flow through any point, and is compact in the Fréchet–Schwartz topology.

Weyl's formula

Main article: Weyl law

Weyl's formula states that one can infer the area A of the drum by counting how rapidly the λ_n grow. We define N(R) to be the number of eigenvalues smaller than R and we get

$A=\omega _{d}^{-1}(2\pi )^{d}\lim _{R\to \infty }{\frac {N(R)}{R^{d/2}}},$

where d is the dimension, and $\omega _{d}$ is the volume of the d-dimensional unit ball. Weyl also conjectured that the next term in the approximation below would give the perimeter of D. In other words, if L denotes the length of the perimeter (or the surface area in higher dimension), then one should have

$N(R)=(2\pi )^{-d}\omega _{d}AR^{d/2}\mp {\frac {1}{4}}(2\pi )^{-d+1}\omega _{d-1}LR^{(d-1)/2}+o(R^{(d-1)/2}).$

For a smooth boundary, this was proved by Victor Ivrii in 1980. The manifold is also not allowed to have a two-parameter family of periodic geodesics, such as a sphere would have.

The Weyl–Berry conjecture

For non-smooth boundaries, Michael Berry conjectured in 1979 that the correction should be of the order of

$R^{D/2},$

where D is the Hausdorff dimension of the boundary. This was disproved by J. Brossard and R. A. Carmona, who then suggested that one should replace the Hausdorff dimension with the upper box dimension. In the plane, this was proved if the boundary has dimension 1 (1993), but mostly disproved for higher dimensions (1996); both results are by Lapidus and Pomerance.

See also

• Gassmann triple
• Isospectral
• Spectral geometry
• Vibrations of a circular membrane

References

• Abikoff, William (January 1995), "Remembering Lipman Bers" (PDF), Notices of the AMS, 42 (1): 8–18
• Brossard, Jean; Carmona, René (1986), "Can one hear the dimension of a fractal?", Comm. Math. Phys., 104 (1): 103–122, Bibcode:1986CMaPh.104..103B, doi:10.1007/BF01210795, S2CID 121173871
• Buser, Peter; Conway, John; Doyle, Peter; Semmler, Klaus-Dieter (1994), "Some planar isospectral domains", International Mathematics Research Notices, 1994 (9): 391–400, doi:10.1155/S1073792894000437
• Chapman, S.J. (1995), "Drums that sound the same", American Mathematical Monthly, 102 (February): 124–138, doi:10.2307/2975346, JSTOR 2975346
• Giraud, Olivier; Thas, Koen (2010), "Hearing shapes of drums – mathematical and physical aspects of isospectrality", Reviews of Modern Physics, 82 (3): 2213–2255, arXiv:1101.1239, Bibcode:2010RvMP...82.2213G, doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.82.2213, S2CID 119289493
• Gordon, Carolyn; Webb, David (1996), "You can't hear the shape of a drum", American Scientist, 84 (January–February): 46–55, Bibcode:1996AmSci..84...46G
• Gordon, C.; Webb, D.; Wolpert, S. (1992), "Isospectral plane domains and surfaces via Riemannian orbifolds", Inventiones Mathematicae, 110 (1): 1–22, Bibcode:1992InMat.110....1G, doi:10.1007/BF01231320, S2CID 122258115
• Ivrii, V. Ja. (1980), "The second term of the spectral asymptotics for a Laplace–Beltrami operator on manifolds with boundary", Funktsional. Anal. I Prilozhen, 14 (2): 25–34, doi:10.1007/BF01086550, S2CID 123935462 (In Russian).
• Kac, Mark (April 1966), "Can One Hear the Shape of a Drum?" (PDF), American Mathematical Monthly, 73 (4, part 2): 1–23, doi:10.2307/2313748, JSTOR 2313748
• Lapidus, Michel L. (1991), "Can One Hear the Shape of a Fractal Drum? Partial Resolution of the Weyl-Berry Conjecture", Geometric Analysis and Computer Graphics, Math. Sci. Res. Inst. Publ., vol. 17, New York: Springer, pp. 119–126, doi:10.1007/978-1-4613-9711-3_13, ISBN 978-1-4613-9713-7
• Lapidus, Michel L. (1993), "Vibrations of fractal drums, the Riemann hypothesis, waves in fractal media, and the Weyl–Berry conjecture", in B. D. Sleeman; R. J. Jarvis (eds.), Ordinary and Partial Differential Equations, Vol IV, Proc. Twelfth Internat. Conf. (Dundee, Scotland, UK, June 1992), Pitman Research Notes in Math. Series, vol. 289, London: Longman and Technical, pp. 126–209
• Lapidus, M. L.; van Frankenhuysen, M. (2000), Fractal Geometry and Number Theory: Complex dimensions of fractal strings and zeros of zeta functions, Boston: Birkhauser. (Revised and enlarged second edition to appear in 2005.)
• Lapidus, Michel L.; Pomerance, Carl (1993), "The Riemann zeta-function and the one-dimensional Weyl-Berry conjecture for fractal drums", Proc. London Math. Soc., Series 3, 66 (1): 41–69, CiteSeerX 10.1.1.526.854, doi:10.1112/plms/s3-66.1.41
• Lapidus, Michel L.; Pomerance, Carl (1996), "Counterexamples to the modified Weyl–Berry conjecture on fractal drums", Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc., 119 (1): 167–178, Bibcode:1996MPCPS.119..167L, doi:10.1017/S0305004100074053, S2CID 33567484
• Milnor, John (1964), "Eigenvalues of the Laplace operator on certain manifolds", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 51 (4): 542ff, Bibcode:1964PNAS...51..542M, doi:10.1073/pnas.51.4.542, PMC 300113, PMID 16591156
• Sunada, T. (1985), "Riemannian coverings and isospectral manifolds", Ann. of Math., 2, 121 (1): 169–186, doi:10.2307/1971195, JSTOR 1971195
• Zelditch, S. (2000), "Spectral determination of analytic bi-axisymmetric plane domains", Geometric and Functional Analysis, 10 (3): 628–677, arXiv:math/9901005, doi:10.1007/PL00001633, S2CID 16324240

External links

• Simulation showing solutions of the wave equation in two isospectral drums
• Isospectral Drums by Toby Driscoll at the University of Delaware
• Some planar isospectral domains by Peter Buser, John Horton Conway, Peter Doyle, and Klaus-Dieter Semmler
  • 3D rendering of the Buser-Conway-Doyle-Semmler homophonic drums
• Drums That Sound Alike by Ivars Peterson at the Mathematical Association of America web site
• Weisstein, Eric W., "Isospectral Manifolds", MathWorld
• Benguria, Rafael D. (2001) [1994], "Dirichlet eigenvalue", Encyclopedia of Mathematics, EMS Press